Our work is supported by affiliate commissions.

30 Baby Shower Game Gift Ideas

No baby shower is complete without playing fun baby shower games to keep your guests entertained. While you may have already found the perfect baby shower favors for your guests, you may be wondering what you should give for baby shower game prizes.

This guide is full of gift ideas for your baby shower game winners. It can be fun to match your party favors and prize ideas to your baby shower theme, or you may choose to go with a pampering, decorative, or food-related gift. Either way, baby shower game prizes should try to appeal to all your guests, since you never know who the prize winner will be!

By Amanda Horner • Published May 2 2022

1. Pretty Pen Set

A great prize idea for your baby shower games is a pretty pen set like this garden floral gel pen set from Rifle Paper Co. Each pen has a different color bright ink (pink, orange, green and blue) with coordinating floral design to brighten up all your writing needs.

2. Pedicure in a Jar

This pretty pedicure in a jar gift set is the perfect baby shower game gift. The jars are available on Etsy and can be custom made to match your baby shower decorations. Each pedicure jar comes with a pumice block, nail clippers, toe separators, nail file, cuticle stick, cotton pads and a nail polish; everything you need for a pampering at-home pedicure!

3. Gift Card Holders

How cute are these handmade diaper shaped gift card holders from Etsy? Made from heavy card stock and buttons, these adorable little holders make a cute prize for a baby shower game winner. Just add a gift card of your choice for a cute and easy prize everyone will love.

4. Tea Mug

Buy on Amazon →

The perfect way to brew a single cup of tea, this tea mug is great for gifting to friends and family at your baby shower. The gift set includes a porcelain lid and mug, with the sweet saying “You are my cup of tea”, and a stainless-steel infuser/tea strainer to brew the perfect cup of tea.

5. Potted Succulent

This adorable potted succulent is a great giveaway for your baby shower game prizes, door prize, or party favors! Available from Etsy, they come as a DIY kit with everything you need to assemble this cute garden pot. Use them as baby shower decorations, then your game winners can choose their favorite succulent plant to take home.

6. Hand Repair Spa Kit

Buy on Amazon →

The perfect pampering gift, this hand repair kit by Burt’s Bees is available on Amazon and comes in a giftable organza pouch. The spa gift set includes three moisturizing hand lotion products and one pair of cotton gloves to hydrate and soften hands.

7. Mason Jar Shot Glasses

Buy on Amazon →

Fill these cute mason jar shot glasses with your favorite beverage, candy, or other small goodies for a fun and unique game prize. Each jar holds 2 oz. and comes with a leak-proof lid. Once the contents are gone, your guest can use them again and again.

8. Heart Cork Coasters

Buy on Amazon →

As your guests gather to shower you with love and baby shower gifts, give some love back by awarding these adorable coasters to your baby shower game winners. These heart shaped cork coasters come in a four pack and are inscribed with the word “love”. A special gift for your guests to remember a special day.

9. Insulated Wine Tumbler

Buy on Amazon →

It may be called a wine tumbler, but this insulated drink cup is a great gift even for non-wine drinkers. Yeti products are great for keeping drinks hot or cold, and this tumbler is the perfect size for enjoying a glass of your favorite beverage outdoors. They come in a range of fun colors to match your theme and for your prize winners to pick from!

10. Manicure Set

Buy on Amazon →

These colorful pocket size manicure sets make a fun baby shower gift for party game winners. Each personal manicure set contains 7 essential tools in a compact, travel size. This is also a great option for the cheap baby shower on a budget, since these cute travel kits come in a pack of three.

11. Baby Bottle Opener

Buy on Amazon →

This combination magnet and bottle opener is a fun giveaway for baby girl baby shower favors or game winners. The pink silicone and metal bottle opener includes the saying “Poppin’ Bottles”, a fun play on words sure to get a laugh from your friends and family!

12. Bath Bomb Gift Set

Buy on Amazon →

Another great pampering gift for your baby shower guests are handmade bath bombs. These are made with pure essential oils which smell wonderful and leave skin soft and moisturized. This gift set includes five colorful bath bombs and a pretty soap flower packaged in a decorative box.

13. Cocktail Scented Candles

Baby shower game winners can keep the party games going at home with these fun cocktail scented candles. This three-piece set includes favorite cocktail scents like margarita, lemon drop and cosmo. One set can easily accommodate three gifts for prize winners.

14. Compliment Coffee Mug

This cute coffee mug is a great prize idea for baby shower party games. Special friends and family will love starting their day with a fun compliment as they enjoy their morning coffee. The pink and white speckled mug is made from durable stoneware and is imprinted with “Good Morning Gorgeous".

15. Fuzzy Sock Cupcakes

Comfy socks are a great prize idea every guest at your baby shower will love. Take this gift idea up a notch with festive sock cupcakes! Fuzzy socks are swirled and packaged in a cute cupcake liner for a super cute presentation that will go great with a sweet baby shower theme.

16. Bath Salt Soak

You don’t need to spend a day at a fancy spa to experience a pampering mineral bath salt soak. This travel size is super convenient and makes a great baby shower game prize. A lavender bath salt soak is a great way to unwind at the end of the day, and leaves skin soft and smooth.

17. Handmade Coffee Cozy

The perfect coffee accessory, these handmade coffee cozies are a great baby shower game prize idea for your coffee loving friends. The textured coffee cozy sleeve is reusable and fits standard size to-go coffee cups. Look fashionable while sipping your Starbucks year-round with this stylish and environmentally friendly coffee mug cozy.

18. Aromatherapy Gift Basket

Give the ultimate pampering prize to your baby shower game winners with a complete aromatherapy gift basket. Available on Etsy, this set is full of Bath and Body Works Eucalyptus & Spearmint Stress Relief products, from shampoo, conditioner, and body lotion to cleansing bars and a bath bomb.

19. Specialty Chocolate

Dylan’s Candy Bar is known for their fun and creative candy gifts. If you are looking for baby shower game prize ideas to fit your fun and colorful baby shower theme, their signature tackle boxes are sure to be a hit. This chocolate lover’s box includes a mix of fun specialty chocolates perfect for gifting.

20. Pacifier Lip Balm

These adorable handmade lip balm holders are perfect for gifting to prize winners at your baby shower! The holders are available on Etsy, then just add an EOS lip balm of your choice. When combined, you will have the cutest pacifier gift idea for your guests to enjoy.

21. Wine Bottle Stoppers

Don’t let an unfinished bottle of wine go to waste! Wine bottle stoppers are a great tool to have on hand to keep an opened bottle fresh. This pack of five reusable wine stoppers feature fun text like “sip back & relax” and “girls night in”, and make a great prize idea for baby shower games.

22. Jewelry Tray

Buy on Amazon →

These pretty little trinket trays are perfect for storing all your small items like earrings, rings, and keys. The colorful bohemian leaf design of this ceramic jewelry tray is fun, elegant, and will fit in any decor. Friends and family will love winning this prize at your baby shower!

23. Baby Making Potion

If you are having a couple’s baby shower and are looking for coed baby shower prizes, these mini bottle tags are a great gender-neutral gift idea. Add these personalized tags to a mini bottle of your favorite spirits for a fun prize guaranteed to be a hit with your party guests.

24. Lip Care Set

This giftable lip care set provides a trio of lip pampering products including a lip scrub, lip balm, and lip gloss. Together, these products will sooth and restore, moisturize, and provide a soft and glossy lip tint. This gift set makes a great prize friends and family will be fighting to win at your baby shower games.

25. Magnetic Picture Frames

Buy on Amazon →

Colorful magnetic picture frames provide the perfect way to display your favorite memories anywhere. These miniature 3-inch photo frames are compatible with small polaroid photos and can be used solo or linked together along the magnetic edges to make fun and creative displays.

26. Tassel Key Chain

Buy on Amazon →

Cute and colorful macrame keychains will be the perfect addition to your baby shower games prize table. The handcrafted bohemian style mini tassels have a natural tone and texture and will look great when used as a key chain or bag charm. A great prize idea and giftable accessory everyone will love!

27. Mimosa Wine Glasses

If your baby shower theme includes brunch, these stemless wine glasses are a cute and funny baby shower game prize idea! Guests will love sipping their morning mimosa out of these stylish wine glasses after they’ve played a fun baby shower game.

28. Canvas Tote Bag

Buy on Amazon →

You can never have enough stylish tote bags! All your guests will be fighting to win your baby shower games to claim this beautiful canvas tote bag by Kate Spade New York as their prize. Features a pretty multicolored floral print on durable canvas, perfect for carrying all your things from books to groceries.

29. Gourmet Popcorn

With 12 different flavors to choose from, there will be a gourmet popcorn for everyone with Maegan's Goodies Gourmet Popcorn. Available on Etsy, these giftable snacks come in unique flavors like cotton candy, jalapeno cheddar and lemon cheesecake to satisfy every taste.

30. Phone Grip

Popsockets PopGrips come in a wide variety of designs and are a great way to give your phone a new look. We love the pretty floral pattern on this cute and versatile phone grip. You can kind find these anywhere from Amazon to Walmart and they are a great prize gift idea for your baby shower games or diaper raffle.